Are we Together (Sproul)?

As a general rule I don’t get excited about Sproul.  He is a Nestorian and his son is a lunatic. Still, this book was relatively good.

Are We Together? A Protestant Analyzes Roman Catholicism

Excellent contrast between Rome and Protestantism. Short on analysis and critique. Offers some pointers towards a critique. What I picked up in this book:

1. Rome’s viwe of justification is analytic: a man is right with God because God makes him right with God. Infused grace. Substance. Not too much to get excited about. ~1. Prot. holds synthetic view. God declares a man to be right. Imputes, by contrast. Further, Rome can’t criticize Reformers for holding to imputation as legal fiction. Rome, too, believes in imputation: Adam’s guilt, merits of the saints transferred, etc.

2. Decent section on Mary. Nice move by showing how Thomas Aquinas rejects key catholic doctrines on Mary. Had a chance to show how the “Hail Mary” prayer’s theology rests on a big mistranslation, but missed it.

3. Good section on the sacraments. He should have spent more time showing how Rome demands an Aristotelian physics for transubstation to work, but Sproul didn’t pursue that route.

4. Section on Scripture was okay. He should have pointed out in passing how the Book of Tobit is so factually inaccurate, that Rome and Orthodox conservatives must abandon inerrancy or the deuterocanonicals.

5. Section on the Church was okay: debate between Cyprianic and Augustinian interpretations of the Church.


About J. B. Aitken

Interests include patristics, the role of the soul in the human person, analytic theology, Reformed Scholasticism, Medievalism, Substance Metaphysics
This entry was posted in Book Review, theology and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Are we Together (Sproul)?

  1. Evan says:

    What way is Sproul nestorian? I don’t pay attention much to what happens in the popular Reformed world.


  2. I suppose you can’t win all the time…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s